AP® CALCULUS AB & BC · UNIT 5

Exploring Behaviors of Implicit Relations

Find tangent lines, classify extrema, and read concavity on curves defined by an equation in both coordinates. Use verified diagrams to see where a slope formula needs a closer look.

Topic 5.12 study notes4 worked examples · 7 practice questionsUpdated 11 November 2026
Calculus notebook with limit and integral symbols, a compass and pencil on an olive and cream study desk

1. Read an implicit relation by branch

An implicit relation gives a condition that two coordinates must satisfy. A single input can have several outputs on the full curve. Near a point, choose the branch whose behavior you want to describe and treat its y as a function of x wherever that makes sense.

First derivative

y′=dydx gives the slope of the chosen branch. Use it to find tangent lines and intervals where the branch rises or falls.

Second derivative

y″=d2ydx2 describes how the slope changes. An implicit second derivative can involve x, y, and y′.

Differentiate the equation with respect to x, use the Chain Rule for expressions in y, and collect the terms containing y′. Substitute a point after you have the derivative relation.

2. Review the derivative rules

Common derivatives along a differentiable branch
ExpressionDerivative with respect to the input
yy′
ynnyn−1y′
xyxy′+y
x2yx2y′+2xy
xy22xyy′+y2
yxxy′−yx2, for x≠0
sinycos(y)y′
eyeyy′
lnyy′y, for y>0
yy′2y, for y>0
sin(xy)cos(xy)(xy′+y)

3. Choose the correct tangent test

For the smooth equations in this lesson, collect the differentiated equation as A+By′=0, where A and B depend on the coordinates. Check the original equation and the two coefficients at each candidate point before dividing.

Which slope test applies at a point on the relation
Coefficient checkWhat to conclude
A=0, B≠0The slope −AB is zero. The tangent is y=y0.
A≠0, B=0Use y as the local input. Then dxdy=−BA=0, so the tangent is x=x0.
A=B=0The slope quotient gives 00. Inspect the nearby branches or use a limit to determine their directions.

At a point (x0,y0) with finite slope m, use y−y0=m(x−x0). For local extrema, check where the derivative is zero or undefined on the chosen branch, and use derivative signs or the Second Derivative Test where it applies.

4. Compare regular tangents and a crossing

The circle has regular tangent points where one coefficient in the derivative relation is nonzero. The folium has a crossing at the origin where both coefficients vanish. The dashed segments show the tangent directions in each case.

Regular tangents on a circle

image/svg+xml Matplotlib v3.11.2, https://matplotlib.org/ −5 0 5 Horizontal position x −5 0 5 Vertical position y
The top and bottom have horizontal tangents. The left and right edges have vertical tangents.

Two branches at a singular point

image/svg+xml Matplotlib v3.11.2, https://matplotlib.org/ −1.0 −0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 Horizontal position x −1.0 −0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 Vertical position y Origin
The blue branch is tangent to the horizontal axis. The purple branch is tangent to the vertical axis. Both contain (0,0).

5. Use derivative signs to classify a branch

For x2+y2=25, the upper and lower branches share the slope formula y′=−xy where y≠0. The sign of y changes how the same formula behaves.

Read the derivative signs on each semicircle
BranchBehavior on the interior
Upper branch, y>0y′>0 on (−5,0) and y′<0 on (0,5). The branch reaches a local maximum at (0,5).
Lower branch, y<0y′<0 on (−5,0) and y′>0 on (0,5). The branch reaches a local minimum at (0,−5).

The second derivative y″=−25y3 is negative throughout the upper branch and positive throughout the lower branch wherever y≠0. Classify the bend on the branch you are using.

6. Four worked examples

Worked example 1

Find a tangent line to a circle

For x2+y2=25, find the slope formula and the tangent line at (3,4).

1 · Differentiate along the branch

2x+2yy′=0
dydx=−xy

This formula applies where y≠0.

2 · Check the point and evaluate its slope

Since 32+42=25, the point is on the circle. Substitution gives m=−34.

3 · Write the tangent line

y−4=−34(x−3)
y=−34x+254

Tangent at the given point

image/svg+xml Matplotlib v3.11.2, https://matplotlib.org/ −5 0 5 Horizontal position x −5 0 5 Vertical position y (3, 4)
The dashed line passes through (3,4) with slope −34.
Worked example 2

Classify the extrema of a tilted ellipse

For x2+xy+y2=3, find the first derivative. Use it to locate and classify the horizontal tangent points.

1 · Apply the Product Rule to the mixed term

The derivative of xy is xy′+y. Collect the terms in y′.

2x+y+(x+2y)y′=0
y′=−2x+yx+2y

This slope formula requires x+2y≠0.

2 · Solve the horizontal tangent condition

Set 2x+y=0, so y=−2x. Substitution in the ellipse gives 3x2=3. The points (−1,2) and (1,−2) both have nonzero denominators.

3 · Use the second derivative at the stationary points

Differentiate 2x+y+(x+2y)y′=0 again. At either horizontal point, all terms multiplied by y′ vanish. The remaining equation gives

y″=−2x+2y

This formula here is evaluated at the stationary points. It gives −23 at (−1,2) for a local maximum, and 23 at (1,−2) for a local minimum.

Extrema and side tangents

image/svg+xml Matplotlib v3.11.2, https://matplotlib.org/ −2 −1 0 1 2 Horizontal position x −2 −1 0 1 2 Vertical position y
The diamonds mark the maximum and minimum height. The circles mark vertical tangents at (−2,1) and (2,−1).
Worked example 3

Find horizontal and vertical tangents on the folium

Find the horizontal and vertical tangents of x3+y3=6xy. Check the origin separately.

1 · Differentiate and keep both coefficients

(y2−2x)y′=2y−x2
y′=2y−x2y2−2x

The quotient applies where y2−2x≠0.

2 · Find the regular horizontal tangent

Use y=x22 in the original equation.

x3+x68=3x3
x3(x3−16)=0

The nonzero solution gives the point

H=(223,243)

At this point y2−2x=2x≠0. The tangent is y=243.

3 · Find the regular vertical tangent

Set x=y22. Interchanging x and y preserves the curve, so the regular point is

V=(243,223)

There y2−2x=0 and 2y−x2≠0. The tangent is x=243.

4 · Check the two branches at the origin

The origin satisfies the relation and gives 00 in the slope quotient. For a non-origin point set t=yx. Substitution gives

x=6t1+t3

As t tends to zero, both coordinates approach zero, and the secant slope t approaches zero. The corresponding branch is tangent to y=0. Swapping the coordinates gives the branch tangent to x=0. Any finite nonzero limiting slope would keep x away from zero in the displayed formula.

Regular tangents and the crossing

image/svg+xml Matplotlib v3.11.2, https://matplotlib.org/ −4 −2 0 2 4 Horizontal position x −4 −2 0 2 4 Vertical position y H V
The loop has its regular horizontal tangent at H and vertical tangent at V. The two branches meet at the origin.
Worked example 4

Find concavity from a second implicit derivative

For x2+y2=25, find y″ at (3,4) and describe the concavity there.

1 · Differentiate the first derivative relation

Start with x+yy′=0. The Product Rule gives

1+(y′)2+yy″=0
y″=−1+(y′)2y

2 · Use the original relation to simplify

Since y′=−xy, the numerator becomes 1+x2y2. Use x2+y2=25 to get

d2ydx2=−25y3

3 · Evaluate on the upper branch

At (3,4), the second derivative is −2564. This expression is negative for nearby points on the upper branch because y>0, so the branch is concave down there.

7. Recognize common implicit relations

Common implicit relations and modeling settings
Shape or settingRelation and what to check
Circlex2+y2=r2
Choose the upper or lower branch.
Ellipsex2a2+y2b2=1
Choose a branch and check the endpoints of its input interval.
Hyperbolax2a2−y2b2=1
The left and right pieces occupy separate regions.
Foliumx3+y3=6xy
Check both branches at the crossing.
Lemniscate(x2+y2)2=a2(x2−y2)
The two loops meet at the origin for a>0.
Related ratesUse the constraint to connect changing quantities. In a time problem, differentiate with respect to time.

8. Seven practice questions

1. Differentiate a circle

For x2+y2=16, find dydx where it exists.

Show solution 1

1 · Differentiate and solve

2x+2yy′=0
y′=−xy

The formula applies for y≠0. At the two side points the tangents are vertical.

2. Differentiate the folium

For x3+y3=6xy, find the slope formula.

Show solution 2

1 · Use the Product Rule and collect the slope terms

The derivative of 6xy is 6y+6xy′. Collect and simplify.

(y2−2x)y′=2y−x2
y′=2y−x2y2−2x

Use the quotient when y2−2x≠0. At the origin, check the two branches separately.

3. Find the slope at a point on an ellipse

Find the tangent slope of x2−xy+y2=3 at (1,2).

Show solution 3

1 · Differentiate the mixed term

2x−y+(2y−x)y′=0
y′=y−2x2y−x

2 · Check the coordinates and evaluate

The point satisfies 1−2+4=3. The slope numerator is zero and its denominator is 3, so the tangent is horizontal with slope 0.

4. Write a circle’s tangent line

Find the tangent line to x2+y2=25 at (4,3).

Show solution 4

1 · Use the point and slope

At the given point, y′=−xy gives m=−43. Use point-slope form.

y−3=−43(x−4)
y=−43x+253

5. Locate the vertical tangents of a circle

Find all points on x2+y2=25 where the tangent is vertical.

Show solution 5

1 · Use the derivative with the coordinates exchanged

When x≠0, differentiate with respect to y and solve.

dxdy=−yx

This derivative vanishes at y=0. The original circle then gives (5,0) and (−5,0), with vertical tangents x=5 and x=−5.

6. Evaluate a second derivative

For x2+y2=9, find d2ydx2 at (0,3).

Show solution 6

1 · Use the circle relation twice

From x+yy′=0, get 1+(y′)2+yy″=0. At (0,3), the first derivative is zero.

y″=−13

The upper branch is concave down near the point.

7. Determine the concavity of a reciprocal branch

Determine the concavity of xy=1 at (1,1).

Show solution 7

1 · Differentiate the product twice

y+xy′=0
2y′+xy″=0

2 · Read the second derivative on the branch

Use y=1x for x≠0. Then y′=−1x2, so

y″=2x3

At x=1, the second derivative is 2. It is positive on the whole positive branch, which is concave up.

Two branches of the reciprocal relation

image/svg+xml Matplotlib v3.11.2, https://matplotlib.org/ −3 −2 −1 0 1 2 3 Horizontal position x −3 −2 −1 0 1 2 3 Vertical position y (1, 1)
The marked point (1,1) is on the concave-up branch. The axes are asymptotes.

9. Write an AP-style justification

To justify a tangent, show that the point satisfies the original relation and explain which derivative condition gives the direction. To justify concavity or an extremum, identify the branch and give the derivative evidence.

AP-style justification

Give evidence for a vertical tangent

Check the point and the derivative condition

At (5,0), the circle equation holds and x≠0. Viewing x locally as a function of y gives dxdy=−yx=0.

State the tangent line

The branch has a vertical tangent at the point, so its tangent line is x=5.

10. Frequently asked questions

When can I use the numerator to find a horizontal tangent?

Check the original relation at the candidate. The numerator must be zero and the denominator must be nonzero in the slope formula.

How do I handle two zero coefficients?

The slope quotient is indeterminate. Analyze the nearby branches or secants. The folium’s origin has a horizontal and a vertical tangent on different branches.

Why can two points with the same input have different concavity?

The second derivative can depend on both coordinates. On the radius-five circle, y″=−25y3 has opposite signs on the upper and lower branches.

11. Continue studying calculus

Review the differentiation technique, then move from rates of change to accumulation in Unit 6.