NUM8ERS Tutoring Center Dubai logo – you can count on us
Book Now
Sign In

AP United States History 2025 Free-Response Questions Set 2 - Expert Solution Guide

Welcome to the definitive solution guide for AP US History 2025 FRQ Set 2. This comprehensive resource provides expert solutions for all free-response questions including Short Answer Questions on Cold War origins and Mary Church Terrell's activism, a Document-Based Question analyzing Gilded Age economic changes, and Long Essay Questions covering colonial, antebellum, and modern American history. Aligned with College Board scoring rubrics, this guide helps students master the analytical and writing skills needed for exam success.

📚 Comprehensive APUSH Study Resources

Access complete study notes, interactive flashcards, and practice quizzes for all 9 units covering 1491-present

Visit AP U.S. History Study Hub

📋 Table of Contents

📊 AP US History FRQ 2025 Set 2 Overview

Set 2 of the 2025 AP United States History exam features carefully designed questions testing your ability to analyze competing historical interpretations, primary sources from reform movements, and economic transformations during the Gilded Age. This set emphasizes historiographical analysis, social reform movements, and economic history.

Section Breakdown & Timing

Section I, Part B
Short Answer Questions
Time: 40 minutes
Questions: 3 SAQs (Q1-2 mandatory, Q3 or Q4 choice)
Points: 9 points total
Weight: 20% of exam score
Section II
Document-Based Question
Time: 60 minutes (15 min reading + 45 min writing)
Topic: Economic changes 1865-1910
Points: 7 points
Weight: 25% of exam score
Section II
Long Essay Question
Time: 40 minutes
Choice: Select 1 of 3 prompts
Points: 6 points
Weight: 15% of exam score

✍️ Short Answer Questions - Complete Solutions

Question 1: Cold War Origins - Historiographical Analysis

📖 Secondary Source ⏱️ 13 minutes 📊 3 points

Question Context

This question presents two contrasting historical interpretations about the origins of the Cold War. Robert Pollard (1985) argues that economic concerns—particularly American desire for global free markets and access to raw materials—drove US Cold War policy. James Patterson (1996) argues that Soviet aggression in Eastern Europe and fears of communist expansion caused the Cold War, placing blame primarily on Soviet actions rather than American policy.

📌 Part A (1 point)

Prompt: Briefly describe one major difference between Pollard's and Patterson's historical interpretations of the origins of the Cold War.

💡 Strategy: Focus on the fundamental disagreement—Pollard emphasizes US economic motivations while Patterson emphasizes Soviet aggression. Make the contrast explicit and clear.

Sample Acceptable Responses:

Answer 1: Pollard argues that the origins of the Cold War were primarily rooted in economic differences and American efforts to create a global free-market system, while Patterson argues that Soviet actions—particularly territorial expansion and oppression in Eastern Europe—brought on the Cold War, making Soviet behavior rather than economic concerns the primary cause.
Answer 2: Source 1 argues that it was the actions and economic policies of the United States that initiated the Cold War as America sought to use economic power to achieve strategic aims, while Source 2 argues that it was American fear of communism's psychological appeal and Soviet territorial ambitions that led to the conflict.
Answer 3: Pollard emphasizes that US policymakers were primarily concerned with economic security and access to markets and raw materials for American corporations, whereas Patterson emphasizes that American officials worried mainly about the ideological threat of communism spreading to unstable countries and the need to contain Soviet expansion.
⚠️ Common Pitfall: Don't just describe each historian's view separately. You must explicitly CONTRAST them by showing how they disagree on the same issue (economic motivations vs. ideological/security concerns).

📌 Part B (1 point)

Prompt: Briefly explain how one event or development from 1940 to 1960 not directly mentioned in the excerpts could be used to support Pollard's interpretation of the origins of the Cold War.

💡 Strategy: Choose evidence showing US using economic tools to achieve foreign policy goals. Focus on programs, policies, or institutions designed to promote American economic interests globally.

Sample Acceptable Responses:

Answer 1: The Marshall Plan (1948) supports Pollard's interpretation because the United States provided over $13 billion in economic aid to rebuild Western European economies, which served the dual purpose of creating markets for American goods and preventing economic desperation that might make Europeans receptive to communism, demonstrating how economic concerns drove US Cold War policy.
Answer 2: The United States created international economic institutions like the International Monetary Fund and World Bank to promote free-market capitalism and integrate non-communist nations into a US-led economic order, supporting Pollard's argument that American leaders used governmental and multilateral agencies to reshape global commercial and financial systems to serve US economic interests.
Answer 3: The United States began campaigns of economic sanctions against the Soviet Union in 1948, including export controls and trade restrictions, which supports Pollard's interpretation that economic conflict was a critical cause of Soviet-American tensions rather than merely ideological or security concerns.
Answer 4: American foreign aid programs like the Truman Doctrine (1947) provided economic and military assistance to Greece and Turkey specifically to prevent communist takeover, illustrating how the United States used its economic power to secure strategic aims and maintain access to vital resources like Middle Eastern oil, supporting Pollard's economic interpretation.

Additional Supporting Evidence:

  • Bretton Woods system establishing dollar as global reserve currency
  • US promotion of free trade through GATT (General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade)
  • CIA interventions in Iran (1953) and Guatemala (1954) protecting American business interests
  • Military-industrial complex expanding American defense spending and manufacturing
  • Point Four Program providing technical assistance to developing nations

📌 Part C (1 point)

Prompt: Briefly explain how one event or development from 1940 to 1960 not directly mentioned in the excerpts could be used to support Patterson's interpretation of the origins of the Cold War.

💡 Strategy: Choose evidence showing Soviet aggressive actions, territorial expansion, or American fears of communist ideology. Focus on events demonstrating that Soviet behavior provoked American response.

Sample Acceptable Responses:

Answer 1: The Second Red Scare and McCarthyism in the late 1940s and 1950s support Patterson's argument that concerns about the spread of communism and its psychological appeal contributed to the start of the Cold War, as Americans used controversial methods including loyalty oaths and blacklists to expose suspected communists, revealing deep-seated fears about communist infiltration of American society.
Answer 2: The Truman Doctrine (1947) stated that the United States must support free peoples resisting subjugation by armed minorities or outside pressures, specifically targeting Soviet expansion in Greece and Turkey. This supports Patterson's argument that US policymakers were primarily focused on containing communist territorial expansion rather than pursuing economic goals.
Answer 3: The Korean War (1950-1953) demonstrates Patterson's interpretation because the United States justified military intervention with the argument that it was preventing the territorial expansion of communism after North Korea invaded South Korea, supporting his claim that American fears about communist expansion contributed significantly to Cold War tensions.
Answer 4: The Berlin Blockade (1948-49), in which the Soviet Union cut off Western access to West Berlin, supports Patterson's argument that Soviet aggressive behavior—particularly oppressing Eastern European neighbors and threatening Western interests—appeared alarming and required Western resistance, making Soviet actions rather than American economic policy the primary cause of the Cold War.

Additional Supporting Evidence:

  • Soviet establishment of satellite states in Eastern Europe (Poland, Hungary, Czechoslovakia, etc.)
  • Soviet development of atomic weapons (1949) escalating arms race
  • Creation of NATO (1949) as defensive alliance against Soviet expansion
  • CIA covert operations justified as preventing communist takeovers
  • NSC-68 (1950) defining containment strategy based on Soviet threat
  • House Un-American Activities Committee investigating communist influence
⚠️ Common Pitfall: Don't confuse Parts B and C! Part B needs evidence of US ECONOMIC motivations (supporting Pollard). Part C needs evidence of SOVIET AGGRESSION or communist ideological threat (supporting Patterson).

Question 2: Mary Church Terrell Speech (1897)

📄 Primary Source ⏱️ 13 minutes 📊 3 points

Question Context

This question analyzes a speech by Mary Church Terrell, the first president of the National Association of Colored Women (NACW), delivered in 1897. Terrell celebrates African American progress since emancipation while calling for continued activism for racial equality, temperance, morality, and racial unity. Her speech reflects the intersection of African American civil rights activism and women's reform movements during the Progressive Era.

📌 Part A (1 point)

Prompt: Briefly describe the author's purpose as expressed in the excerpt.

💡 Strategy: Identify what Terrell wants to accomplish with this speech. Consider her audience (NACW members) and the calls to action she makes.

Sample Acceptable Responses:

Answer 1: Terrell's purpose was to celebrate the achievements African Americans had made since emancipation, acknowledging the "unprecedented advancement made by the negro" while simultaneously challenging African American women to continue participating in public discussions regarding equality and to actively work for civil rights, temperance, and moral reform.
Answer 2: Terrell sought to inspire and mobilize African American women to take leadership roles in advocating for racial equality and social reform, calling them to "engage intelligently and continuously" in public questions affecting their legal status and to "strike a blow for equality and right whenever and wherever possible."
Answer 3: The author's purpose was to oppose racial discrimination in the United States by establishing African American women's organizations as forces for social change, emphasizing the need to practice "race unity, race pride" while working on issues including temperance, morality, and legal equality.

Key Elements of Terrell's Purpose:

  • Celebrate post-emancipation progress while acknowledging ongoing challenges
  • Call for continued activism and public engagement
  • Establish moral authority for African American women's leadership
  • Promote racial unity and pride
  • Connect racial equality to broader reform movements (temperance, morality)

📌 Part B (1 point)

Prompt: Briefly explain how one historical development between 1865 and 1897 contributed to the ideas expressed in the excerpt.

💡 Strategy: Identify developments that either created opportunities for African American progress (which Terrell celebrates) OR created challenges requiring continued activism (which motivates her call to action).

Sample Acceptable Responses:

Answer 1: The emancipation of enslaved people resulting from the Civil War and the Thirteenth Amendment gave African Americans their freedom, which allowed many to pursue education, establish businesses, enter politics, and build institutions—the "unprecedented advancements" that Terrell acknowledges in her speech as evidence of African American capability and progress.
Answer 2: The passage of constitutional amendments during Reconstruction—the Thirteenth (ending slavery), Fourteenth (granting citizenship and equal protection), and Fifteenth (protecting voting rights)—led to temporary political and social gains for African Americans that Terrell celebrates, while also establishing a legal framework for the continued fight for equality that she advocates.
Answer 3: The Supreme Court decision Plessy v. Ferguson (1896), issued just one year before Terrell's speech, upheld racial segregation under the "separate but equal" doctrine, enforcing legal discrimination and leading activists such as Terrell to organize advocacy groups like the NACW to fight for civil rights through alternative means when the courts failed to protect equality.
Answer 4: The rise of Jim Crow laws throughout the South following the end of Reconstruction in 1877, which imposed racial segregation and disenfranchised Black voters through literacy tests, poll taxes, and violence, demonstrated that the fight for equality would need to continue despite formal constitutional protections, motivating Terrell's call for sustained activism.
Answer 5: The growth of women's reform movements in the late nineteenth century, particularly the temperance movement led by organizations like the Women's Christian Temperance Union, contributed to Terrell's emphasis on women's public activism and her call for African American women to join broader conversations regarding "temperance and morality" as a way to "better humanity and elevate the race."

Additional Relevant Developments:

  • Establishment of historically Black colleges and universities (HBCUs) promoting education
  • Growth of Black churches as community institutions
  • Ida B. Wells' anti-lynching crusade revealing ongoing racial violence
  • Booker T. Washington's Atlanta Compromise (1895) debating strategies for advancement
  • Formation of Black women's clubs addressing community needs

📌 Part C (1 point)

Prompt: Briefly explain how the ideas expressed in the excerpt contributed to one historical development between 1897 and 1945.

💡 Strategy: Show how Terrell's specific ideas—civil rights activism, women's reform movements, temperance, racial unity—led to or influenced later developments. Make a clear cause-effect connection.

Sample Acceptable Responses:

Answer 1: Calls for temperance expressed by Terrell and other reformers eventually led to the constitutional amendment establishing Prohibition (Eighteenth Amendment, 1920-1933), demonstrating how the reform advocacy that Terrell promoted contributed to significant changes in American law and society, even though Prohibition ultimately proved difficult to enforce and was later repealed.
Answer 2: The fight for equality for women illustrated in Terrell's arguments—particularly her insistence that women should "engage intelligently and continuously" in public questions—eventually contributed to the women's suffrage movement that achieved voting rights through the Nineteenth Amendment (1920), expanding women's political participation and power.
Answer 3: Efforts to reform United States society through organized advocacy, exemplified by Terrell's establishment of the NACW, contributed to the rise of the broader Progressive movement in the late 1890s and early 1900s, which sought to address social problems including poverty, corruption, labor conditions, and inequality through systematic reform and government action.
Answer 4: The formation of organizations such as the National Association of Colored Women, which Terrell led, eventually contributed to a broader and more organized civil rights movement against legal segregation in the United States, including the establishment of the NAACP (1909) and the legal challenges that culminated decades later in Brown v. Board of Education (1954).

Key Connections to Make:

  • Temperance → Prohibition: Reform advocacy led to constitutional change
  • Women's Activism → Suffrage: Public engagement led to voting rights
  • Organized Reform → Progressive Era: Systematic approach to social problems
  • Racial Unity → Civil Rights Movement: Foundation for 20th century activism
  • Black Women's Leadership: Intersection of race and gender in reform

Questions 3 & 4: No-Stimulus SAQs (Choice)

📚 Knowledge-Based ⏱️ 13 minutes 📊 3 points

Important: Choose EITHER Question 3 OR Question 4 based on your content knowledge!

Question 3: Colonial Period to Early Republic (1763-1840)

📌 Part A (1 point)

Prompt: Briefly describe one political debate in British North America from 1763 to 1783.

Sample Acceptable Responses:

Answer 1: After the Seven Years' War ended in 1763, British North American colonists engaged in heated debates about whether they should be taxed by Parliament to help pay for war debts, with colonists arguing "no taxation without representation" since they lacked direct representation in Parliament, while British officials claimed Parliament had sovereign authority to tax all British subjects.
Answer 2: The Proclamation of 1763, which prohibited colonial settlement west of the Appalachian Mountains, sparked political debates about westward expansion, with colonists who wanted access to western lands conflicting with British officials who sought to avoid expensive wars with Native Americans and maintain control over colonial expansion.
Answer 3: During the 1770s, colonists vigorously debated whether they should declare independence from Great Britain or remain loyal to the Crown, with Patriots arguing that British violations of colonial rights justified separation while Loyalists maintained that rebellion was treasonous and that the colonies benefited from British protection and trade.

Additional Examples: Quartering Act debates, debates over Stamp Act and other taxes, Intolerable Acts responses, Continental Association enforcement, debates about forming state governments.

📌 Part B (1 point)

Prompt: Briefly describe one effect of the ratification of the United States Constitution from 1789 to 1800.

Sample Acceptable Responses:

Answer 1: The ratification of the Constitution created a new, stronger central government for the United States with three branches—legislative (Congress), executive (President), and judicial (Supreme Court)—each with defined powers and checks and balances, replacing the weak confederation government under the Articles of Confederation.
Answer 2: The ratification led to the eventual addition of the Bill of Rights (1791), the first ten amendments to the Constitution, which guaranteed individual liberties including freedom of speech, religion, and press, as Anti-Federalists had demanded protections for individual rights as a condition for supporting the Constitution.
Answer 3: The establishment of a new government under the Constitution led to the formation of the first political parties in American history—the Federalists (led by Hamilton) who supported strong central government and the Democratic-Republicans (led by Jefferson) who advocated for states' rights—as Americans disagreed over how to interpret constitutional powers.
Answer 4: The ratification created lasting debates over states' rights versus federal power under the federalist system, as seen in conflicts over whether the federal government had implied powers (as Hamilton argued) or only explicitly enumerated powers (as Jefferson argued), debates that would continue throughout American history.

📌 Part C (1 point)

Prompt: Briefly explain how one group responded to debates about federal government power from 1800 to 1840.

Sample Acceptable Responses:

Answer 1: In response to states passing laws that conflicted with federal authority, the Supreme Court under Chief Justice John Marshall asserted the power to strike down state laws through judicial review, as in McCulloch v. Maryland (1819) which upheld federal supremacy and broadly interpreted federal powers, strengthening the national government's authority over states.
Answer 2: Advocates of internal improvements, particularly Whigs following Henry Clay's American System, claimed that the federal government had constitutional authority to fund roads, canals, and other infrastructure projects to promote economic development and national unity, arguing for a broad interpretation of federal powers under the Constitution's commerce and general welfare clauses.
Answer 3: Native American tribes, particularly the Cherokee Nation, resisted federal government encroachment onto their sovereign lands by pursuing legal strategies, as in Worcester v. Georgia (1832) where the Supreme Court ruled Georgia had no authority over Cherokee territory, though President Andrew Jackson refused to enforce the decision, leading to the Trail of Tears.
Answer 4: During the Nullification Crisis (1832-33), South Carolina asserted that states had the right to nullify federal laws they deemed unconstitutional, particularly the protective tariffs they called the "Tariff of Abominations," arguing that federal power was limited and that states retained sovereignty, though President Jackson threatened military force to uphold federal authority.

Question 4: Progressive Era to Cold War (1910-1970)

📌 Part A (1 point)

Prompt: Briefly describe one political debate in the United States between 1910 and 1929.

Sample Acceptable Responses:

Answer 1: A growing Progressive movement led to political debates about the federal government's role in regulating business and protecting consumers and workers, with Progressives advocating for antitrust enforcement, pure food and drug laws, labor protections, and women's suffrage, while conservatives argued that such regulations infringed on economic freedom and property rights.
Answer 2: After World War I ended in 1918, Americans vigorously debated whether the United States should join the League of Nations and take on international commitments to maintain peace, with President Wilson supporting membership to prevent future wars while isolationists, led by Republican senators, argued that the League would entangle America in foreign conflicts and violate national sovereignty.
Answer 3: The First Red Scare (1919-1920) resulted in political debates about labor rights, socialism, and free speech, as the federal government conducted raids arresting suspected radicals and anarchists, while civil libertarians argued that these actions violated constitutional rights and reflected xenophobia rather than legitimate security concerns.
Answer 4: Americans engaged in intense debates over immigration restriction, culminating in the Immigration Act of 1924 (National Origins Act) which established quotas heavily favoring northern and western Europeans while restricting southern and eastern Europeans and essentially banning Asian immigration, with supporters citing concerns about assimilation and preserving American culture while opponents decried racism and discrimination.

📌 Part B (1 point)

Prompt: Briefly describe one effect of the New Deal from 1932 to 1945.

Sample Acceptable Responses:

Answer 1: The New Deal created a limited welfare state through programs like Social Security (1935), which provided retirement pensions for elderly Americans, unemployment insurance, and aid to dependent children, fundamentally changing the relationship between citizens and the federal government by establishing an ongoing obligation to provide for citizen welfare that continues today.
Answer 2: The New Deal increased employment and built infrastructure through work relief programs like the Works Progress Administration (WPA) and Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC), which employed millions of Americans to construct roads, bridges, schools, parks, and public buildings, leaving a lasting physical legacy while providing immediate economic relief during the Depression.
Answer 3: The New Deal established the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC), which employed young men to work on environmental conservation projects in national parks and forests, planting trees, building trails, and preventing soil erosion. This program had lasting impacts on public lands and established a precedent for government environmental programs.
Answer 4: The Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA), created as part of the New Deal, built hydroelectric dams and power plants in the Tennessee Valley region, bringing electricity to rural areas for the first time, controlling flooding, and spurring economic development, demonstrating the federal government's capacity for large-scale regional planning and infrastructure investment.

📌 Part C (1 point)

Prompt: Briefly explain how one group responded to debates about government power from 1945 to 1970.

Sample Acceptable Responses:

Answer 1: Conservatives, including Republicans and southern Democrats, increasingly criticized the expansion of the welfare state by calling for limiting the role of the federal government, with figures like Barry Goldwater (1964 presidential campaign) and later Ronald Reagan arguing that Great Society programs created dependency, wasted taxpayer money, and infringed on individual freedom and states' rights.
Answer 2: Supporters of President Lyndon Johnson's Great Society praised the federal government for waging a "War on Poverty" through programs like Medicare (health insurance for elderly), Medicaid (health insurance for poor), Head Start (preschool education), and food stamps, arguing that the federal government had a moral obligation to address poverty and inequality.
Answer 3: Members of the New Left, including Students for a Democratic Society (SDS), argued that political leaders were not doing enough to transform the racial and economic status quo, criticizing both Democratic and Republican establishments for maintaining inequality, prosecuting the Vietnam War, and failing to address systemic injustice, calling for participatory democracy and radical social change.
Answer 4: Communities across the South and North questioned and resisted the federal government's role in desegregation efforts following Brown v. Board of Education (1954), with some white southerners engaging in "massive resistance" including closing public schools rather than integrating, demonstrating opposition to federal enforcement of civil rights and racial equality.

📝 Document-Based Question - Gilded Age Economic Changes

DBQ: Economic Changes and US Society (1865-1910)

📄 7 Documents ⏱️ 60 minutes 📊 7 points

The Prompt

"Evaluate the extent to which economic changes influenced United States society between 1865 to 1910."

This DBQ spans the Gilded Age and early Progressive Era, asking you to assess how profoundly industrialization, railroad expansion, corporate consolidation, and labor conflicts transformed American society. The prompt asks for the EXTENT of influence—meaning you must evaluate how much economic changes shaped society across multiple dimensions (politics, social structure, reform movements, etc.).

Document Analysis & Evidence

📄 Document 1: Francis Vinton Sermon (1869)

Source: Minister's sermon celebrating completion of transcontinental railroad

Content Summary: Describes railroad as "great event," promoting free trade, uniting nation, populating territory, preserving Union of states after Civil War

Use in Your Essay:

  • Evidence: Shows how economic development (railroads) was seen as having political benefits (national unity)
  • Situation: Written shortly after Civil War when national unity was fragile, making railroad's connecting function politically significant
  • Purpose: As a minister, Vinton sought to give moral/religious blessing to economic development, suggesting Americans saw economic progress as part of national destiny
  • Connection: Demonstrates belief that economic changes would fundamentally reshape American society by binding regions together
📄 Document 2: Henry George, Progress and Poverty (1879)

Source: Journalist/politician analyzing relationship between economic growth and poverty

Content Summary: Argues enormous increase in productive power has not eliminated poverty; increased wealth builds great fortunes but doesn't help those who toil; poverty amidst progress is "great enigma of our times"

Use in Your Essay:

  • Evidence: Shows economic changes created wealth inequality and social problems rather than universal prosperity
  • Situation: Written during height of Gilded Age when industrialists accumulated vast wealth while workers faced harsh conditions
  • Purpose: George sought to convince readers that economic system needed reform, influencing Progressive movement
  • Complexity: Creates nuance in argument—economic changes brought both progress AND social problems
📄 Document 3: Lucy Parsons Interview (1886)

Source: Formerly enslaved woman and labor activist interviewed in St. Louis newspaper

Content Summary: Claims monopolies destroying middle class; predicts revolutionary class struggle between possessing and non-possessing classes; cites widespread strikes as evidence wage system no longer satisfies workers' needs

Use in Your Essay:

  • Evidence: Shows economic changes intensified class conflict and labor activism
  • POV: As formerly enslaved woman, Parsons understood economic exploitation and dominated labor, making her critique of industrial capitalism particularly powerful
  • Situation: 1886 was year of Haymarket Affair, demonstrating labor unrest reaching crisis point
  • Audience: Speaking to working-class newspaper readers, seeking to mobilize them for collective action
📄 Document 4: Benjamin Harrison Speech (1894)

Source: Former Republican president supporting Republican congressional candidates

Content Summary: Defends American manufacturers and factories; criticizes Democrats for portraying employers as "robber-barons"; argues factories benefit society by providing employment; calls for end to class hostility

Use in Your Essay:

  • Evidence: Shows political debates directly shaped by economic changes and class tensions
  • POV: As Republican and former president, Harrison represented pro-business interests who benefited from industrial capitalism
  • Audience: Speaking to voters in election campaign, using economic issues to gain political advantage
  • Purpose: Sought to convince voters that Republican pro-business policies benefited all Americans
  • Contrast: Directly conflicts with Parsons (Doc 3), showing multiple perspectives on industrialization
📄 Document 5: M.E.J. Kelley, "The Union Label" (1897)

Source: Female labor reformer writing in North American Review

Content Summary: Describes union label system allowing consumers to buy goods from fair-wage factories; argues consumers have ethical responsibility; when people refuse to buy sweatshop goods, sweatshops will disappear

Use in Your Essay:

  • Evidence: Shows how economic changes sparked reform movements seeking to improve working conditions
  • Audience: Middle-class consumers who had purchasing power to influence manufacturing
  • Purpose: Kelley sought to mobilize consumers as agents of social change, demonstrating how economic relationships created new forms of activism
  • Gender: Written by woman, showing women's reform movements addressing industrial economy
📄 Document 6: "Industrial Leadership" Article (1900)

Source: New York Times article celebrating industrial managers

Content Summary: Argues "hero of future is Captain of industry"; success comes from producing most goods most cheaply; engineers and managers must influence government so "industry and commerce" shape national policy

Use in Your Essay:

  • Evidence: Shows how economic changes created new social values celebrating businessmen as national heroes
  • Purpose: Author wants readers to believe industrial leaders deserve political influence based on economic expertise
  • Situation: Around 1900, business leaders increasingly pursued imperial policies opening foreign markets
  • Connection: Links domestic industrial changes to foreign policy through economic imperialism
📄 Document 7: Political Cartoon "The Trust Buster" (1903)

Source: Cartoon from Minneapolis Journal showing Theodore Roosevelt

Content Summary: Depicts TR riding horse labeled "The Trusts" with bridle labeled "trust control laws"

Use in Your Essay:

  • Evidence: Shows Progressive Era government responses to corporate consolidation
  • POV: Anti-trust perspective supporting government regulation of monopolies
  • Situation: By early 1900s, trust consolidation had concentrated enormous economic power, prompting Progressive reforms
  • Political Impact: Demonstrates how economic changes transformed role of government and presidency

Crafting Your Thesis

Strong Thesis Example 1: Economic changes from 1865 to 1910, particularly rapid industrialization and corporate consolidation, profoundly influenced United States society by creating stark wealth inequality that sparked both labor activism and Progressive reform movements, transforming American politics from questions of sectional conflict to debates about the role of government in regulating the economy and protecting workers.
Strong Thesis Example 2: Between 1865 and 1910, economic transformations including railroad expansion, factory production, and the rise of monopolistic trusts fundamentally reshaped American society by intensifying class divisions, spurring labor organizing and strikes, generating Progressive reforms seeking to regulate corporate power, and creating new social values that both celebrated industrial "captains" as heroes and condemned "robber barons" as exploiters.
Strong Thesis Example 3: The extent to which economic changes influenced US society from 1865 to 1910 was profound and pervasive, as industrialization transformed not just production methods but also class structures, political debates, reform movements, and cultural values, with Americans deeply divided between those celebrating industrial progress and those demanding protection from its social costs.

Contextualization Examples

Contextualization 1: Before the Civil War, the United States remained primarily agricultural with most Americans living on farms and working as independent producers. The war itself accelerated industrial development as the North built factories to produce weapons, uniforms, and supplies, creating infrastructure and manufacturing capacity that would drive postwar economic transformation. Additionally, the end of slavery eliminated a major sectional conflict, allowing national politics to focus increasingly on economic questions.
Contextualization 2: The economic developments of 1865-1910 laid the groundwork for American participation in World War I, as the nation's industrial capacity would prove crucial for war production. The Progressive reforms of this era, including increased government regulation of business, also established precedents for the expanded federal role during WWI and later during the New Deal.

Outside Evidence Examples

Specific Evidence Beyond Documents:

  • Andrew Carnegie, John D. Rockefeller, J.P. Morgan—specific industrialists
  • Vertical and horizontal integration—business practices
  • Haymarket Riot (1886), Homestead Strike (1892), Pullman Strike (1894)
  • Sherman Antitrust Act (1890)
  • Knights of Labor, American Federation of Labor—union organizations
  • Social Gospel movement
  • Settlement houses (Jane Addams' Hull House)
  • Muckrakers (Ida Tarbell, Upton Sinclair)
  • Populist Party representing farmers hurt by economic changes

Sourcing Strategy

Sourcing Example 1: Document 3's historical situation is crucial to understanding labor radicalism. Lucy Parsons spoke in 1886, the same year as the Haymarket Affair in Chicago, when a labor rally ended in violence and bombing that killed police officers. This context of escalating labor conflict explains why Parsons predicts revolutionary class struggle, as the violence demonstrated that industrial capitalism's tensions had reached a crisis point where strikes were becoming increasingly common and confrontational.
Sourcing Example 2: Document 4's audience is essential to understanding its argument. Benjamin Harrison spoke to voters in an 1894 congressional election campaign, meaning his defense of manufacturers as job creators rather than "robber-barons" was designed to gain political support for Republican candidates. This shows how economic changes so profoundly influenced society that politicians believed they could win or lose elections based on their positions regarding industrial capitalism and class relations.

📖 Long Essay Questions - Overview

The LEQ requires you to write a 6-point essay in 40 minutes without documents. Choose the prompt you know best!

LEQ Option 2: British Colonists and Environment (1607-1754)

Prompt: Evaluate how British colonists in the Americas adapted to their environments from 1607 to 1754.

Key Evidence:

  • Cash Crops: Tobacco (Virginia/Maryland), rice/indigo (South Carolina), sugar (Caribbean)
  • Regional Adaptation: New England rocky soil → fishing/shipping; Middle colonies → grain; South → plantations
  • Labor Systems: Indentured servitude → Atlantic slave trade as climate/crops required more labor
  • Geography: Settlement near rivers/harbors for transportation and trade
  • Climate Impact: Hot, disease-ridden Caribbean → high mortality → increased slave imports
💡 Thesis Approach: British colonists adapted to American environments by developing regional economies based on climate and geography, with northern colonies focusing on commerce and mixed farming due to poor soil while southern colonies established plantation agriculture producing cash crops that required intensive labor, leading to the expansion of African slavery particularly in warm climates suitable for tobacco, rice, and sugar cultivation.

LEQ Option 3: Sectional Tensions (1800-1848)

Prompt: Evaluate how sectional tensions shaped United States society from 1800 to 1848.

Key Evidence:

  • Missouri Compromise (1820): Drew line at 36°30', balanced slave/free states
  • Nullification Crisis (1832-33): SC claimed right to nullify federal tariffs
  • Economic Differences: North industrializing vs. South plantation economy
  • Political Parties: Whigs/Democrats trying to maintain national unity; Free Soil Party emerging
  • Abolitionism: Garrison's Liberator, Frederick Douglass, Underground Railroad
  • Mexican-American War (1846-48): Territorial expansion intensifying slavery debates
💡 Thesis Approach: Sectional tensions over slavery and economic policy profoundly shaped American society from 1800 to 1848 by dividing political parties along regional lines, spurring the growth of both proslavery and abolitionist movements, creating constitutional crises like the Nullification Crisis, and ultimately preventing national consensus on westward expansion as the Mexican Cession intensified debates about whether new territories would be slave or free.

LEQ Option 4: Economic Changes (1960-2000)

Prompt: Evaluate how United States society responded to economic changes from 1960 to 2000.

Key Evidence:

  • Deindustrialization: Rust Belt factory closures, manufacturing decline
  • Service Economy: Shift from industrial to information/service jobs
  • Technology: Personal computers, Internet creating new industries
  • Globalization: NAFTA (1994), increased trade with China
  • Sun Belt Growth: Population and economic migration to South/Southwest
  • Stagflation (1970s): Challenged Keynesian economics, led to Reaganomics
  • Income Inequality: Wealth gap widening in 1980s-90s
💡 Thesis Approach: American society responded to late 20th century economic changes—particularly deindustrialization, technological innovation, and globalization—through geographic migration from Rust Belt to Sun Belt, political shift toward conservatism and deregulation under Reagan, growing income inequality between college-educated workers in expanding service/tech sectors and displaced industrial workers, and embrace of free trade agreements that integrated the US into global economy while accelerating manufacturing decline.

🎯 Master Strategies for Success

SAQ Success Formula

  • Complete Sentences Required: Bullet points = 0 points, even if content is correct
  • Specific Details Matter: Name people, dates, events. "Reformers wanted change" is too vague
  • Answer ALL Parts: Skipping Part C means losing 1/3 of possible points
  • Historical Accuracy: Minor errors OK if overall content is correct
  • Time Budget: 13 minutes per question = 4 min each part. Don't write essays!

DBQ Excellence Checklist

  • ✓ Read Prompt First: Know what you're looking for before reading documents
  • ✓ Annotate Documents: Note POV, purpose, connections between docs
  • ✓ Group Documents Thematically: Don't write one paragraph per document
  • ✓ Use 4+ Documents: For full evidence points (aim for all 7 for complexity)
  • ✓ Source 2+ Documents: Explain WHY POV/purpose/situation/audience matters
  • ✓ Add Outside Evidence: At least one specific fact not in documents
  • ✓ Contextualize Early: First or second paragraph
  • ✓ Write Thesis Last: After you know what evidence you have

🚫 Critical Mistakes to Avoid

  • Document Dumping: "Doc 1 says... Doc 2 says..." Use documents to support ARGUMENTS
  • Weak Thesis: "Economic changes happened" restates prompt. Say HOW they influenced society
  • Identifying Without Explaining: Don't just say "Doc 3's purpose was to mobilize workers"—explain how that matters
  • Missing Time Period: Using evidence from 1950 for 1865-1910 prompt earns 0 points
  • No Argumentation: Essays must make arguments, not just describe
  • Vague Generalizations: "People disagreed about stuff" provides no specific information

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Pollard's and Patterson's Cold War interpretations? ▼
Pollard argues the Cold War originated primarily from economic conflicts, with the US seeking to create a global free-market system and secure access to raw materials for American corporations. Patterson argues the Cold War resulted from American fears of Soviet territorial expansion and the psychological appeal of communist ideology to unstable countries. Essentially, Pollard blames American economic imperialism while Patterson blames Soviet aggression and the ideological threat of communism.
What was Mary Church Terrell's purpose in her 1897 address? ▼
Terrell's purpose was multifaceted: (1) Celebrate African American achievements since emancipation, (2) Challenge African American women to continue participating in public advocacy for equality and civil rights, (3) Call for engagement in temperance and moral reform movements, (4) Promote racial unity and pride, and (5) Establish the National Association of Colored Women as a force for social change. She sought to mobilize Black women as leaders in both racial justice and broader Progressive reform movements.
How should I structure my Gilded Age DBQ essay? ▼
Introduction: Contextualize (pre-Civil War economy or post-1910 developments) and present thesis evaluating the EXTENT of economic influence. Body paragraphs: Organize thematically (e.g., wealth inequality, labor conflicts, political responses, reform movements). Use 4+ documents as evidence, explaining what they show about economic changes' impact. Include outside evidence (specific people, events, laws). Source 2+ documents by analyzing POV/purpose/situation/audience. Conclusion: Synthesize argument and potentially demonstrate complexity by acknowledging multiple perspectives or explaining both continuity and change.
What evidence supports Pollard's economic interpretation of Cold War? ▼
Key evidence includes: Marshall Plan (1948) providing economic aid to connect European economies to US, International economic institutions (IMF, World Bank) promoting free-market capitalism, Economic sanctions against Soviet Union, Foreign aid programs to non-communist countries, CIA interventions in Iran (1953) and Guatemala (1954) protecting American business interests, and Bretton Woods system establishing dollar as global reserve currency. All demonstrate US using economic tools to achieve foreign policy goals.
Which LEQ option should I choose for Set 2? ▼
Choose Option 2 (British colonists 1607-1754) if you're strong on colonial history, regional differences, cash crops, and labor systems. Choose Option 3 (sectional tensions 1800-1848) if you know Missouri Compromise, Nullification Crisis, abolitionism, and antebellum politics well. Choose Option 4 (economic changes 1960-2000) if you're confident with deindustrialization, technology, globalization, Reagan era, and contemporary history. Pick the period where you can cite the MOST specific examples with names and dates.
What developments contributed to Mary Church Terrell's 1897 ideas? ▼
Key developments: Emancipation and Reconstruction amendments (13th-15th) giving African Americans freedom and rights, Reconstruction-era political gains (Black officeholders), End of Reconstruction (1877) and rise of Jim Crow segregation, Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) legalizing "separate but equal," Women's temperance and reform movements providing model for activism, Lynching and racial violence creating urgent need for advocacy, Black church and community institutions providing organizational base, and Growth of Black women's clubs addressing community needs.
How did economic changes influence society 1865-1910? ▼
Economic changes profoundly influenced society: Social structure - Created sharp wealth inequality between industrialists and workers, destroyed middle class artisans. Labor - Sparked union formation, massive strikes (Haymarket, Homestead, Pullman). Politics - Shifted from sectional to economic debates; Populist and Progressive movements emerged. Reform - Social Gospel, settlement houses, muckrakers addressing industrial problems. Class consciousness - Workers and farmers organized to challenge corporate power. Government role - Increased regulation (antitrust, pure food/drug laws). Values - Competing views of industrialists as "captains of industry" or "robber barons."
What evidence shows Soviet responsibility for Cold War? ▼
Evidence supporting Patterson: Soviet control of Eastern Europe (Poland, Hungary, Czechoslovakia, etc.), Berlin Blockade (1948-49) cutting off West Berlin, Support for communist movements in Greece and Turkey, Korean War (1950) showing communist territorial expansion, Creation of NATO (1949) as defensive response to Soviet threat, Second Red Scare revealing American fears of communist infiltration, Soviet atomic weapons (1949) starting arms race, and Soviet rejection of Marshall Plan preventing economic cooperation.
How do I earn the complexity point? ▼
Earn complexity by: (1) Explaining both continuity AND change (e.g., economic changes transformed labor relations BUT artisan traditions persisted in some crafts), (2) Discussing multiple perspectives (Harrison celebrating factories vs. Parsons predicting revolution), (3) Explaining multiple causes AND effects, (4) Making insightful connections across periods (Gilded Age inequality similar to 1920s/today), (5) Using all 7 documents effectively in DBQ, or (6) Sourcing 4+ documents. Must be woven into argument, not just added phrases.
What's the best way to source documents? ▼
Effective sourcing requires two steps: (1) Identify the POV/purpose/situation/audience, then (2) EXPLAIN how it's relevant to your argument. Example: "Lucy Parsons, as a formerly enslaved woman who became a labor activist (POV), understood economic exploitation and dominated labor systems firsthand, giving her critique of monopolies particular credibility among working-class audiences (relevance). Her 1886 interview occurred during the year of the Haymarket Affair (situation), when labor unrest had reached crisis levels, explaining her prediction of revolutionary class struggle (relevance to argument about intensifying social conflict)." Always connect sourcing to your thesis!

🚀 Complete Your APUSH Preparation

Master all 9 units of American history from colonial period to present day. Access comprehensive notes, interactive flashcards, challenging quizzes, and exam strategies designed by expert educators.

Start Studying Now →